The Ultimate Guide to Website Compliance in 2025: SEC, FCA, and More

Understanding the Risks of Non-Compliance

Failing to meet website compliance standards isn’t just an oversight—it’s a direct threat to your business. Here’s what’s at stake:

• Hefty Fines: Regulatory bodies are ramping up enforcement.  The figures for the second half of 2024 are not yet available, but from July 2023 to June 2024, ASIC imposed $92 million in penalties for online compliance failures. The SEC and FCA have been equally vigilant, issuing multimillion-dollar fines for misleading advertisements and poor record-keeping practices. ‍
• Reputational Damage: Non-compliance can erode trust with clients, investors, and stakeholders. A single regulatory breach can dominate headlines and tarnish your brand image, potentially leading to client loss and diminished market confidence. ‍
• Operational Disruptions: When regulators come knocking, they expect you to have your records in order. Firms without robust archiving and record-keeping processes often face lengthy audits, resource-intensive investigations, and legal battles—all of which drain time and money.

Real World Examples

• SEC Action: In 2023, a U.S.-based financial advisory firm was fined $4 million for failing to provide sufficient evidence of compliance with the Marketing Rule. Their inability to archive dynamic website content led to allegations of misleading advertising. ‍
• FCA Enforcement: A UK firm faced a $2.5 million penalty in 2024 for burying key risk disclosures in fine print on its website, violating FCA Consumer Duty guidelines. ‍
• ASIC Crackdown: An Australian investment firm was fined $1.8 million after regulators uncovered inconsistencies between website promotions and internal performance records.

Proactive Compliance is Key

The takeaway? Compliance isn’t just about avoiding penalties; it’s about future-proofing your business. By investing in robust tools like MirrorWeb to capture, archive, and manage your digital content, you can navigate audits with ease, maintain client trust, and stay ahead of regulatory changes.

This guide is here to simplify the complex world of website compliance. Whether you’re navigating the SEC’s Marketing Rule, adhering to FCA Consumer Duty standards, or meeting ASIC’s stringent expectations, we’ve got you covered. Read on to learn how to keep regulators happy, avoid costly pitfalls, and position your firm for success.

The SEC Marketing Rule: What You Need to Know

The U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission’s (SEC’s) Marketing Rule was approved in December 2020 and enacted on May 4, 2021. From that point, Registered Investment Advisers (RIAs) had an 18-month transition period to fully adhere to it until November 4, 2022.  

The Marketing Rule modernized the existing Advertising Rule 206(4)-1, which had remained largely unchanged since its adoption in 1961 -  an era that predated digital communications. Think of this as bringing the Advertising Rule out of the Mad Men era and into the digital age.  

Here’s the gist: your website is an advertisement. And that means it’s subject to seven no-nonsense prohibitions:

1. No untrue statements or omissions.
2. No claims you can’t back up.
3. No misleading implications or inferences.  
4. No skimming over risks or limitations.
5. No cherry-picking performance results.
6. No unfair presentation of specific investment advice.
7. Absolutely no material misrepresentation.

In short, it’s not compliant if it’s not 100% fair and balanced. The burden of proof? That’s on you. Every claim and every piece of content needs to be backed up and cataloged. Why? Because when the SEC comes knocking, “I’ll get back to you” won’t cut it.  

FINRA Rule 2210: Keep It Fair, Balanced, and Honest

FINRA Rule 2210 is all about transparency and good faith. Your website communication should:

• Be clear and fair.
• Provide a solid foundation for evaluating facts.  
• Avoid overblown claims and buried disclaimers.  

Translation? Please don’t make your audience feel they need a magnifying glass and a law degree to understand your site. Be upfront, be honest, and keep the fine print readable.

The FCA’s Consumer Duty: Clarity Above All

Across the pond, the UK’s Financial Conduct Authority (FCA) has its own playbook. At it’s core?  “Fair, clear and, not misleading” communications. This mantra isn’t just a suggestion but the backbone of their Consumer Duty strategy.

To stay compliant:

• Balance claims with key risks.
• Avoid making past performance data the star of the show.
• Ensure consumers have all the info they need to make informed decisions – no gimmicks, no gloss.  

Expect trouble if your website tries to sugarcoat risks or buries disclosures in the fine print. The FCA isn’t here for shortcuts.

ASIC’s Stance: Content is King

The Australian Securities and Investments Commission (ASIC) plays by similar rules. Content is scrutinized over the channel it’s shared on, and compliance is non-negotiable. The numbers don’t lie: from July 23 to June 2024, $92 million worth of civil penalties were enforced as part of an ongoing push around consumer protection online.  

To stay on ASIC’s good side, your website content must:

• Be truthful and accurate.
• Be stored in a way that’s searchable and auditable.
• Keep evolving to meet new formats and expectations.  

Failing to capture and preserve your website’s content could result in a costly audit or, worse, losing consumer trust.  

How to Prove Compliance

When it comes to compliance, it’s not just about following the rules—it’s about being able to prove you’ve done so. With regulators increasing their scrutiny, here are the steps to stay audit-ready:  

• Document Everything: Keep detailed records of all marketing materials, website updates, and disclaimers. Regulators want a clear trail of evidence. ‍
• Leverage Technology: Use advanced tools to capture and archive dynamic website content in real time. Static screenshots are not enough. ‍
• Prepare for Audits: Immediately ensure all records are searchable, exportable, and audit-ready. ‍
• Be Proactive: Regularly review your website and materials to catch potential compliance issues before regulators do.  

Imagine this: A regulator asks for proof of your website content 18 months ago. With the right solution, you can replay an exact snapshot of your site in seconds. That’s the power of dynamic archiving.  

Record-Keeping Best Practices  

Record-keeping is the backbone of compliance, and doing it right can save you from hefty fines and reputational damage. Here’s how to create a solid record-keeping strategy:  

• Capture Everything: Archive all website changes, disclaimers, and communications in their native formats. ‍
• Automate Processes: Manual record-keeping is error prone. Automation ensures accuracy and reduces workload. ‍
• Organize and Catalog: Structure your records for easy retrieval during audits or legal reviews. Categorize by date, content type, or regulatory requirement. ‍
• Secure Your Data: Store records in a compliant, secure manner that meets GDPR or other regional privacy standards.  

Pro Tip: Screenshots and PDFs won’t cut it. Regulators expect dynamic, interactive content that mirrors the original user experience.

‍The Secret Sauce: Record-Keeping That Works  

Here’s the kicker: proving compliance is as critical as achieving it. Regulators want airtight evidence, which is where record-keeping comes in. Capturing dynamic content, cataloging it for audits, and ensuring it’s easily retrievable – that’s the key to staying ahead of the curve.  

Why get bogged down in endless manual reviews when technology can do the heavy lifting for you?  

Why Communications Supervision Solutions are Your Secret Weapon