Join the Community

21,611
Expert opinions
43,772
Total members
414
New members (last 30 days)
153
New opinions (last 30 days)
28,573
Total comments

Lack of Governance in UK Financial Services sector

1 comment

This is example is indicative of the state of financial services governance in the UK:

In 2000, Egg (internet-based credit card company), suffered a major data loss and could only recover account records by cobbling together messages from their CRM system. As a customer at the time, I challenged the accuracy of my account statement and demanded to see my full customer account record. They refused to provide anything other than the CRM record, so I told them that I would be happy to pay my account just as soon as they amended their account records to reflect an accurate balance.

Egg held out for two years, during which I tried to gain access to my records by an appeal to the FSA, the UK's financial services regulator. They refused my appeal on the basis of the records belonging to Egg, not the customer. I further initiated the involvement of the UK's Financial Services Ombudsman, who is empowered to investigate such matters. In order to halt the Ombudsman's investigation, Egg took me to court. Despite the Banking Code stipulating that companies should not proceed with litigation until an Ombudsman's investigation was complete, Egg used litigation to prevent an Ombudsman's investigation, despite a direct appeal from the Ombudsman.

We went to court (which was notable, the judge being on very friendly, first-name terms with Egg's lawyer, and extremely rude and aggressive towards me). Despite having filed their case on the basis of a balance that Egg had claimed was correct for two years, the first thing the judge did was allow Egg to amend their balance to that which was claimed by me. In effect, I was now in court over an action by Egg for an agreed amount! The judge then awarded £22,000 of costs to Egg. At the costs hearing, the judge very aggressively addressed a note-taking journalist directly, asking why the newspaper thought there was a worthwhile story. Within 24 hours the newspaper pulled the story on the grounds that Egg had threatened to sue them and they couldn't afford a long and expensive court case with a major source of advertising revenue.

My experience taught me that corruption within the UK is systemic and pervades every aspect of the financial services sector, the regulator and the judiciary. I wrote publicly at the time, that if my experience was typical, there was a significant public risk, if such practices were tolerated elsewhere in the system. It doesn't take much of a leap to understand that the FSA's primary mandate 'to preserve confidence in the UK financial services sector' ultimately works against the public interest.

External

This content is provided by an external author without editing by Finextra. It expresses the views and opinions of the author.

Join the Community

21,611
Expert opinions
43,772
Total members
414
New members (last 30 days)
153
New opinions (last 30 days)
28,573
Total comments

Now Hiring