08 February 2016

US judge backs bank against customer who sued over hack

08 June 2011  |  7640 views  |  3 arrow on screen

A US judge magistrate has ruled that a bank is not responsible for the loss of around $345,000 from a business customer account following a cyber-attack.

Magistrate judge John Rich has recommended that a US District Court in Maine grant Ocean Bank's motion for a summary dismissal of the complaint filed by Patco Construction Company.

Rich's order - first reported by BankInfoSecurity - comes after Patco Construction Company sued Ocean bank in the wake of a 2009 cyber-attack.

Malware was used to steal the firm's online banking credentials which the crooks then tapped to make ACH transactions worth nearly $600,000. Around $243,000 worth of payments were blocked by the bank once the fraud was discovered.

However, Patco sued Ocean for the remaining $345,000, arguing that the bank should have spotted the fraud and stopped it. The construction firm also argues that by not requiring customers to use multi-factor authentication, Ocean does not use best practice.

Ocean argued that having verified IDs, passwords and requested challenge response questions, it acted in good faith by processing the ACH payments and Patco was to blame for letting its details become compromised.

Rich concludes that, although Ocean could have done more to authenticate users, the law does not require banks to use the "best" possible security measures and customers are aware of what is on offer when they sign up.

Comments: (3)

Bruce Shirey - The Rinaldi Group - San Diego | 08 June, 2011, 15:21

Seriously? Does Magistrate judge John Rich have part ownership or family in Ocean's bank management?  Under this farce of a ruling, Heartland, TJX and others should be off the hook for their breaches AND be entitled to get the millions of dollars paid in fines back.  Bank customers, like Patco Construction expect, safety and security for their money, not some legal fine print or worse, a lame intereptation from this judge that the Ocean's bank policy is to "try really hard" to protect its customer assets.  

Be the first to give this comment the thumbs up 0 thumb ups! (Log in to thumb up)
Michael Kyritsis - ACI - London | 09 June, 2011, 08:57

This is different to the situation of Heartland, TJX, etc - in which card details were compromised beloning to people who had not signed up for any card services with those companies.

Patco Construction Company signed up for Ocean's banking services and accepted the online banking credentials.

If this gets enough press coverage Ocean might lose a lot of customers, presumably to banks that have implemented multi-factor authentication.

Be the first to give this comment the thumbs up 0 thumb ups! (Log in to thumb up)
Ketharaman Swaminathan - GTM360 Marketing Solutions - Pune | 09 June, 2011, 16:53

The popularity of Mint, OfferMatic, BillGuard and other services that directly access the customer's bank account on the basis of a simple username and password suggests that two factor authentication solutions haven't been implemented by many US banks so many years after it was mandated by FFIEC. Against this backdrop, it's interesting to note that, while the court ruling holds a bank liable for compliance with FFIEC's mandate, it considers Password + Security Question as adequate implementation of 2FA although most security industry professionals won't think so. 

Be the first to give this comment the thumbs up 0 thumb ups! (Log in to thumb up)
Comment on this story (membership required)
Log in to receive notifications when someone posts a comment

Finextra news in your inbox

For Finextra's free daily newsletter, breaking news flashes and weekly jobs board, sign up now.

Related blogs

Create a blog about this story (membership required)

Related stories

07 June, 2011
28 April, 2011
15 April, 2011
21 January, 2011
21 May, 2010
10 March, 2010
13 November, 2009
04 November, 2009
29 September, 2009
Your browser is unable to support Flash files.

Top topics

Most viewed Most shared
Fintech rising: Resistance is futile, says...
10841 views comments | 48 tweets | 41 linkedin
Digital transformation driving earnings at...
9149 views comments | 43 tweets | 36 linkedin
ECB eyes up European P2P payments
7744 views comments | 28 tweets | 38 linkedin
Visa opens up to developers
7500 views comments | 23 tweets | 40 linkedin
It may take ten years, but blockchain tech...
6347 views comments | 20 tweets | 19 linkedin

Featured job

to $120K base, double OTE, benefits
New York City, NY or Boston, MA (USA)

Find your next job